Menu
Sign up Sign in

AI SL · 12.9

Differentiation

12.9.10

Harder tangent and normal problems

12.9.10

Harder tangent and normal problems

Target: I can find the points on a curve whose tangent passes through a given point, using a general point \((p, q)\). (+4 more)

By the end of this section

Key points

Unknown point, given information

  • If the point of contact is not given, call it \((p, q)\). It is on the curve, so \(q=f(p)\).
  • The tangent at that point is \(y-q=f'(p)(x-p)\).
  • Put the given point (or the given condition) into this equation. You get an equation in p. Solve it, then find q.
  • There may be two answers: two tangents can be drawn from a point outside a parabola.

Parallel, perpendicular and equal gradients

  • Parallel lines have equal gradients: a tangent parallel to \(y=5x+1\) has gradient 5.
  • Perpendicular lines have gradients that multiply to \(-1\): a normal perpendicular to \(y=5x+1\) is the same as a tangent parallel to it.
  • To find where a curve has gradient k, solve \(f'(x)=k\). To find where the gradient equals the y-coordinate, solve \(f'(x)=f(x)\).
  • If \(f'(a)=0\), the tangent is horizontal and the normal is the vertical line \(x=a\).

The normal meeting the curve again

  • Write the equation of the normal. Then set the curve equal to the normal and solve.
  • You already know one solution: the x-value of the point you started from. The other solution is the new point.
  • For a curve with a fraction such as \(\frac{2}{x}\), multiply through by x to get a polynomial equation.

Show that questions

  • Keep the letter (a or k) in the working: do not replace it with a number.
  • Write every line. Finish with a sentence saying what you have shown, for example that the area is 8 for every a.
  • Use the polynomial solver or factorising to check quadratics and cubics. In a show that question, the factors are the evidence.

On the calculator

Derivative at a point

Menu > Calc > Derivative at a point

  • Use it for \(x\sqrt{x+5}\), \(\frac{1}{x+6}\), \(x^2e^x\) and other curves you cannot differentiate by hand.
  • If the result is 0, the tangent is horizontal and the normal is vertical.

Screenshot and video to come

Solving the equation for p

Menu > Algebra > Polynomial Tools

  • Write the equation in p with 0 on one side.
  • Enter the coefficients from the highest power down and read the real roots.

Screenshot and video to come

Worked examples

Problems like the ones in class. Pick one, try it, then open the working.
Tangent through a point not on the curve

The tangent at a point on the curve \(y=x^2+5\) passes through the point \((1, -3)\). Find the possible coordinates of the point of contact.

−4−224−10102030xyy = x² + 5(1, −3)
Working
  1. A general point

    Let the point be \((p, q)\). Then \(q=p^{2}+5\)

    The point is unknown, so give it letters. It is on the curve, so q is found from p.

  2. Tangent at that point

    Tangent: \(y-q=(2p)(x-p)\)

    The gradient is \(\frac{dy}{dx}\) with \(x=p\), which is \(2p\).

  3. Use the given point

    It passes through \((1, -3)\): \(-3-(p^{2}+5)=(2p)(1-p)\)

    The tangent passes through \((1, -3)\): put \(x=1\) and \(y=-3\) into its equation.

  4. Solve for p

    Simplify (multiply through if there is a fraction): \(p^{2} - 2 p - 8=0\); \(p=-2 \text{ or } p=4\)

    A quadratic in p. Solve by factorising or with the polynomial solver.

  5. Points

    Points: \((-2, 9)\) and \((4, 21)\)

    Find q for each p using \(q=p^2+5\). Two tangents can be drawn from the point.

Video walkthrough coming
Where the normal meets the curve again

Find the coordinates of the point where the normal to the curve \(y=x^2-2x\) at the point where \(x=3\) meets the curve again.

Working
  1. The normal

    \(\frac{dy}{dx}=2x-2\), so at \(x=3\) the tangent gradient is \(4\) and \(y=3\); Normal gradient \(-\frac{1}{4}\): \(y-3=-\frac{1}{4}(x-3)\), so \(y=-\frac{1}{4}x+\frac{15}{4}\)

    Find the tangent gradient and the point, then the normal as in the last lesson.

  2. Curve equals normal

    Curve = normal: \(x^2-2x=-\frac{1}{4}x+\frac{15}{4}\)

    Where the normal meets the curve, both give the same y.

  3. A quadratic

    Multiply through and collect: \(4 x^{2} - 7 x - 15=0\)

    Multiply by 4 to clear the fraction. Collect everything on one side.

  4. The other root

    \(x=3\) is a root (the point you started from). The other root is \(x=-\frac{5}{4}\)

    You already know \(x=3\) is a solution, so the other root is the new point. Use the polynomial solver to check.

  5. The point

    \(y=\frac{65}{16}\), so the normal meets the curve again at \((-\frac{5}{4}, \frac{65}{16})\)

    Put the new x into the curve.

Video walkthrough coming
Tangent parallel to a line

Find the equation of the tangent to the curve \(y=x^2-4x+3\) that is parallel to the line \(2x-y=7\).

Working
  1. Gradient of the line

    \(2x-y=7\) is \(y=2x-7\), so the gradient is 2

    Parallel lines have equal gradients.

  2. Gradient equals 2

    \(2x-4=2\) gives \(x=3\), and \(y=0\)

    Set \(\frac{dy}{dx}=2\) and solve for x.

  3. Equation

    \(y=2(x-3)\); \(y=2x-6\)

    Use the point of contact and the gradient 2.

Video walkthrough coming
Finding a constant from a normal

The normal to the curve \(y=\frac{a}{x}\) at the point where \(x=3\) is parallel to the line \(3x-y=4\). Find the value of the constant a.

Working
  1. Tangent gradient

    \(y=ax^{-1}\), so \(\frac{dy}{dx}=-ax^{-2}\). At \(x=3\) this is \(-\frac{a}{9}\)

    The constant a stays in the working.

  2. Normal gradient

    \(m_{normal}=-1\div\left(-\frac{a}{9}\right)=\frac{9}{a}\)

    Turn the gradient upside down and change the sign.

  3. Line gradient

    \(3x-y=4\) is \(y=3x-4\), gradient 3

    The normal is parallel to this line, so it has gradient 3.

  4. Solve

    \(\frac{9}{a}=3\), so \(a=3\)

    A single equation in a.

Video walkthrough coming
A triangle with a fixed area

The tangent to the curve \(y=\frac{4}{x}\) at the point where \(x=a\) (\(a>0\)) meets the y-axis at P and the x-axis at Q. O is the origin. Show that the area of triangle OPQ is the same for every value of a.

Working
  1. Tangent at x = a

    At \(x=a\): \(y=\frac{4}{a}\) and gradient \(-\frac{4}{a^2}\); Tangent: \(y-\frac{4}{a}=-\frac{4}{a^2}(x-a)\)

    Keep a as a letter. Write \(y=4x^{-1}\), so \(\frac{dy}{dx}=-4x^{-2}\).

  2. P and Q

    P is where \(x=0\): \(y=\frac{4}{a}+\frac{4}{a}=\frac{8}{a}\), so \(P=\left(0, \frac{8}{a}\right)\); Q is where \(y=0\): \(x-a=a\), so \(Q=(2a, 0)\)

    P is on the y-axis (\(x=0\)). Q is on the x-axis (\(y=0\)).

  3. Area

    Area \(=\frac{1}{2}\times 2a\times\frac{8}{a}=8\)

    The a cancels, so the area is 8 whatever the value of a. Say this in a sentence.

Video walkthrough coming
A tangent that meets the curve again

Show that the tangent to the curve \(y=x^3-3x+2\) at the point with x-coordinate k meets the curve again at the point with x-coordinate \(-2k\).

Working
  1. Tangent at x = k

    \(\frac{dy}{dx}=3x^2-3\), so at \(x=k\) the gradient is \(3k^2-3\); At \(x=k\), \(y=k^3-3k+2\). Tangent: \(y=(3k^2-3)(x-k)+k^3-3k+2\)

    Keep k as a letter.

  2. Curve equals tangent

    Curve = tangent: \(x^3-3x+2=(3k^2-3)(x-k)+k^3-3k+2\); \(x^3-3k^2x+2k^3=0\) (the other terms cancel)

    Subtract and collect. The terms in the gradient and the constant cancel to leave a short cubic.

  3. Factorise

    \((x-k)^2(x+2k)=0\), because expanding gives \(x^3-3k^2x+2k^3\)

    The double factor \((x-k)^2\) is the tangent touching the curve at \(x=k\).

  4. Conclusion

    \(x=k\) is the point of contact (a repeated root). The other root is \(x=-2k\), so the tangent meets the curve again there.

    End with a sentence. This is a check of a given result, not a proof of a general theorem.

Video walkthrough coming
A horizontal tangent

Using technology, find the equation of the normal to the curve \(y=3+x^2e^{-2x}\) at the point where \(x=0\).

Working
  1. Gradient

    From the calculator: derivative of \(3+x^2e^{-2x}\) at \(x=0\) is \(0\)

    The tangent is horizontal.

  2. Why this matters

    \(-1\div 0\) is not a number

    A horizontal tangent has a vertical normal. You cannot use \(m_{normal}=-\frac{1}{m}\).

  3. The point

    \(y=3+0=3\), so the point is \((0, 3)\)

    A vertical line through this point.

  4. Answer

    \(x=0\)

    The normal is the line \(x=0\), the y-axis.

Video walkthrough coming